Type to search

‘Puppies aren’t human beings’: Attorney in puppy tossing case sparks outrage in court

‘Puppies aren’t human beings’: Attorney in puppy tossing case sparks outrage in court


COACHELLA, Calif. (WFLA/CNN) – An lawyer drew audible gasps and outrage in a court docket this week with comments he made in the course of the case of a girl accused of dumping dogs in a California dumpster.
“As the law is written, dogs aren’t human beings,” the legal professional stated.
The legal professional, who has not been named, is defending Deborah Culwell. Culwell is charged with seven counts of animal cruelty after police say she tossed week-vintage puppies right into a Coachella dumpster. Officers later located 38 other puppies at her home.
Her lawyer on Thursday argued that her bail shouldn’t be elevated because the crimes she’s accused of include animals – not humans.
“I couldn’t believe that. Are puppies not human beings? Well, they are a residing being,” Katie Phillips stated. “And I cherished when the entire audience gasped when he had the gall to say that approximately those precious creatures of the earth.”
Two of the puppies Culwell, is accused of tossing now stay at Phillips’ home. She’s elevating them earlier than they locate theirs for all time home.
“Well, I assume from the day they were born, they had been probable isolated and saved far from humans. They don’t even know what human contact is all about; it’s now not a very good issue. It’s a frightening element,” she said.
One of the seven dogs that were thrown away later died. Culwell relinquished possession of all of her animals.
Don Jackson, of the Sports Group, says UA Athletics Director Dave Heeke admitted underneath sworn testimony that he had no understanding of violations by using Phelps.
The assistant coach turned into suspended indefinitely in February while Heeke said the branch turned into moving to fire Phelps.
The University stated in a statement at that point the movement became “no longer related to the federal criminal complaints in New York or the NCAA’s review of the information underlying the allegations of illegal conduct.”
Phelps had been suspended all through the 2017-18 season for five days to violate NCAA rules.
Jackson’s statement states that Senior Associate Athletics Director Krystal Swindlehurst implied that Phelps became “terminated because of a personal battle.”
“The moves of University of Arizona representatives, in particular, Athletics Director Heeke amount to defamation,” Jackson said within the assertion.
He believes the move to take away Phelps turned into made with the aid of UA to assist them doubtlessly get a lesser degree of sanctions from the NCAA for infractions that Jackson says Phelps changed into not a part of.
“Coach Phelps has been rendered unemployable in college basketball,” Jackson’s declaration read.
UA Athletics may want to discover as soon as July what infraction its guys’ basketball crew is going through due to a former assistant teach Book Richardson’s federal conviction inside the NCAA Bribery Scandal.

Elizabeth Coleman

I am a lawyer by profession and a blogger by passion. I started blogging to express my views on various issues.The blog has now become one of my passions. After seeing so many of my friends and colleagues using blogs for their business purposes, I decided to share my views through my blog.I love reading other people's blogs. I am trying to write one every day, and sometimes when I have time I write two or three posts per day.