Type to search

Shamima Begum: Sajid Javid labelled ‘ethical coward’ over toddler loss of life

Child Law

Shamima Begum: Sajid Javid labelled ‘ethical coward’ over toddler loss of life


Sajid Javid has been accused of moral cowardice and “treating the United Kingdom as a banana republic” to pursue his management aims following the dying of Jarrah, the three-week-old son of Isis bride Shamima Begum.

A Church of England bishop and a former director of public prosecutions led the refrain of outrage directed at the house secretary as a call grew for him to study his controversial decision to strip the 19-12 months-old of British citizenship – a pass that left her stateless and her infant in felony limbo.

Syrian camps: inclined kids of Isis left out via the outside global
Read more
“This became an abject decision via a home secretary reputedly so rationale on furthering the management pursuits that he has overlooked sovereignty, treating the UK as a banana republic incapable of regulating its very own residents,” stated Lord Macdonald, who became director of public prosecutions of England and Wales between 2003 and 2008.

The peer, who oversaw a 2010 government evaluate of counter-terrorism and security powers, instructed the Observer that Javid’s “opportunism has different prices, which include a greater risky global in which stateless individuals roam without an allegiance, and the demise of unprotected innocents, in this situation a prone British infant.” And he warned of blowback to the UK.

“No dignified self-governing nation should abandon obligation for its very own residents on this way, trying to dump them directly to poorer international locations with failed safety arrangements. Mr. Javid’s behavior is a recipe for refugee chaos and moral cowardice of the worst sort,” he said.

The bishop of St Albans, the Rt Rev Dr. Alan Smith, stated: “She needs to come returned, be well interviewed and, if it’s located that she has broken the regulation, she should face the law. If it’s determined that she has been radicalized, she must receive help and help.

“The home secretary must make sure people in this u. S. A. Are covered. We ought to have done this by way of taking her via due process, and it’s far to be regretted if we are not following it, due to the fact this is a human rights issue.”

Home secretary Sajid Javid
Home secretary Sajid Javid. Photograph: -/AFP/Getty Images
From Bethnal Green, east London, Begum was 15 while she and different schoolgirls went to enroll in Isis in February 2015. She gave delivery in a Syrian refugee camp last month, having already lost two youngsters.

News that a third child had now died has left her family in London distraught. The Begum circle of relatives’ attorney, Tasnime Akunjee, said: “They are utterly beaten and despondent at the moment.”

Javid’s selection to strip the teen of her British citizenship prompted a ferocious debate over whether or not she ought to be allowed to return and raised questions about the legality of his selection.

Shadow home secretary Diane Abbott tweeted the day before today: “It is towards international law to make someone stateless, and now an innocent infant has died due to a British female being stripped of her citizenship. This is callous and inhumane.”

Guardian Today: the headlines, the analysis, the controversy – despatched directly to you
Read more
Lib Dem domestic affairs spokesperson Ed Davey stated: “Many folks feared this tragic final results while the house secretary washed his fingers of Britain’s responsibility for a British citizen and a British infant. If the courts sooner or later show he has acted illegally in making a British citizen stateless, we will bear in mind this infant in keeping him to account.”

Several fellow Conservative MPs have also expressed anger at Javid’s role. Bracknell MP Phillip Lee stated he became deeply concerned by choice, which he believed became “driven by using a kind of populism.”

Anna Soubry, who left the Tories to join the Independent Group, tweeted that Javid must now repair Begum’s citizenship. “Shamima Begum is our obligation, something she may additionally or might not have executed, however abhorrent her views,” she said.

There are claims that Javid did not seek advice from either the legal professional general or the solicitor’s favorite earlier than making his decision, something that would depart him prone in the occasion of a criminal mission. When asked if this changed into the case, a Home Office spokesman said: “We do now not touch upon individual cases.”

Javid confirmed the final month that Jarrah changed into a British citizen and stated that he had considered the kid’s hobby while identifying to revoke Begum’s citizenship. But he instructed the Commons home affairs committee that it might be “tremendously tough” for the government to facilitate the go back of a child from Syria.

Conservative party chairman Brandon Lewis defended Javid. “The domestic secretary can have had advice, and I recognize he decided primarily based on what’s inside the countrywide hobby and the safety of humans here inside the UK,” Lewis stated. “There is not any query that the responsibility of a domestic secretary on this united states is to maintain British humans safe.”

The Begum family inside the UK are understood to be exploring their prison options, together with bringing a private prosecution in opposition to the home secretary. Tasnime Akunjee said he’ll soon be flying out to Syria to help Begum prepare her enchantment. “I’m going to Syria to satisfy any person who has misplaced three children so that I can display her a few pretty dense paperwork, and so I can obtain her signature. It’s ridiculous,” said the attorney.

Begum’s father, Ahmed Ali, talking to the BBC from Bangladesh earlier than he discovered out his daughter’s toddler had died, apologized to the British humans but asked for his or her forgiveness, pronouncing his daughter need to be allowed returned to the UK and “punished if she had made any mistake.”

“She became underage at that time; she couldn’t remember that much. I assume a person encouraged her to try this,” he said. “I admit that she may have performed incorrectly without realizing it.”

Outside the east London mosque on Saturday, few people wanted to discuss Begum’s state of affairs. “I don’t need to talk shit and be placed on a few watch lists for saying I experience sorry for her,” said one guy in his 20s. “What she did change into incorrect, but what they’ve achieved is worse. They used all this energy of the country towards a teenage lady and her toddler – and for what?”

In a Punjabi cafe in Whitechapel, a family of four has been cut up of their views. Parents Sobia and Rizwan mentioned whether or not Javid was right to disclaim Begum the chance to go back to the United Kingdom.

“I don’t suppose he did it with proper purpose,” said Sobia. “I understand why he did it, due to the fact he needs to reveal he won’t be gentle on Muslims. However, that changed into a child’s lifestyle. He punished a harmless infant.”

However, her husband said it became vital to illustrate that there are critical consequences to joining Isis. Did he believe the choice to make her stateless? “Now not now, due to the fact her toddler has died, and we are presupposed to be a civilized u. S. But what’s the law around it? We need to be the usage of the right legal guidelines. Why aren’t the authorities going via their policies?”

Elizabeth Coleman

General food buff. Incurable zombie junkie. Extreme tv nerd. Creator. Basketball fan, father of 3, record lover, Saul Bass fan and communicator, collector, connector, creator. Operating at the sweet spot between minimalism and programing to develop visual solutions that inform and persuade. Concept is the foundation of everything else.